Paul - 1984. "I Guess That's Why They Call It The Blues" by Elton John. His drunken walk and wailing arm says it all, he was definetly all over the place. His ending note was so off and his voice was completley horse. He sounded really sick. J. Lo said that he has so much quality and even though he has a sinus problem he still got the audience on their feet. Randy said he wouldn't give him a pass and he was pitchy through out half the song. But he likes the fact he can make the song his own. Steven agrees with Randy and defines him as a "cool dude with a loose mood". He seems ok for now but with a little more time and rest he will be back in no time. Hope he does well.
Thia - 1995. "Colors of the Wind" Vanessa Williams. Obviously this song means a lot to Native Americans and people who remember Pocahontas will love it. She seemed to go a little to quickly and I don't think she could hit the lower notes that Vanessa usually did but Randy said that the vocals were ok. Boos all around. He said he was bored and was at a pageant and it wasn't unique and she needs to take some chances. It just seemed so safe. Steven thinks she sang beautifully but she didn't sing the right song. J. Lo said she has an Adele quality but she was too safe and vibrato was too strong and didn't feel as though she was out of the box. I think she was a little too scared and the fact that she probably didn't really know the songs that were on the choice list. I wasn't too happy with it and the way she sang but whatever right? 
James Durbin -1989. "I'll Be There For You" by Bon Jovi
Singing in perfect pitch since he was 2 years old. Rocking his leather studded headband, walking around the stage and hitting those high notes you know it's James. He seemed a little too pitchy to me in some parts but the kid from Santa Cruz is not that bad. Steven didn't understand singing to the dolls. He asked him not to get too poppy (as in doing pop music. Obviously some really good rock songs were released in 1989 but he didn't want to do them)...He said he didn't want to spoil Aerosmith and promised when he sings it for the finale, Steven agreed he will sing it with him. J. Lo loves it and he brings her so much joy. Randy agrees with me that he was pitchy but the fact that he didn't over due the high note.
Haley- 1990. "I'm Your Baby Tonight" Whitney Houston
Here is Whitney wannabe Number 1! Rocking the Spandex pants, high heels and bright red shirt. She looked like she fit the 80's but her voice didn't. J. Lo she says she (Haley) feels tense and doesn't know what to do. She is trying to perform and doesn't feel it naturally. Ryan licked his finger and wiped some make up off her chin. Randy doesn't feel what she knows what she is. From Alicia to Country to Whitney she doesn't know what kind of musician she is. Steven feels she has a Janis Joplin voice towards the end and she might be more blues than anything since her mom and dad were singers. She really needs to work on herself but as a young person, Haley needs to know that she needs to figure out who she admires and her voice sounds like. Took me years to figure it out.
Stefano - 1989 "If You Don't Know Me By Now" by Harold Melvin & the Blue Notes
This kid's runs are better than drinking coffee in the morning and ending up in the bathroom. His high note was great and he killed this song. Smiles all around. Steven "Beautiful phrasing" and "best performance of the night" said by Randy. If he connected more to the audience it would have been better J. Lo said. Had to show mom some love. This was probably the best song ever!!! I promise you that you would love this song if you download it on iTunes. All proceeds go straight to Japan Relief Efforts.
Pia- 1988 "Where do Broken Hearts Go" Whitney Houston
OMG Whitney Houston #2 wannabe again!!! Rocking what looks to be a one piece white suit...what an amazing voice. She got the audience on their feet but seems as though she was glued to the floor. No movement what so ever. Randy said You are why this show is called American Idol.Amazing vocals and is really in it to win it. J. Lo was happy she did something up tempo. She is perfect. Steven didn't even really get a chance to say anything. It wasn't terrible but please no more Whitney songs. I feel I am gonna want some crack after this show. (Whitney and Bobby Joke)
Scotty - 1993 "Can I Trust You with My Heart" Travis Tritt
Tritt proud. And while it was fine, it was nothing new from him, despite Jimmy Iovine's earlier advice that he try to "grow" this week. Steven said Keep knowing who you are and you will go places. I just hope at some point they will have him do some Josh Turner. His voice just makes me melt.
Karen - 1989 "Love Will Lead You Back"-Taylor Dayne
Don't really remember this song that well. She actually did something crazy with her hair. Like a Padame/Marge Simpson look. I guess she decided to go back and do a little more Spanglish as to put herself in front again and get those Latino votes. Randy: It's better than last week but he wasn't jumping up and down. Steven: Love the ethnicness. J. Lo said to play her strengths. Perform from the heart. She wasn't my favorite this week so I guess she is going to be in the bottom again!
Casey - 1991 "Smells Like Teen Spirit" by Nirvana
Come on, first time using a Bass and vocals as well and being the first to sing a Nirvana song on American Idol in ten seasons. First of all love this song!!! I remember the video!!! Wow!!! Loved the lighting...Steven: SO crazy and so talented, perfect match! J. Lo Big shoes to fill. (Kurt Cobain) It's got a little bit screechy and screamy. Wish it had a little bit more pleasant feel though. Still thinks he is sexy Randy: I love you put art first. Not best vocal but you are fearless and that's what we need! Gotta say this guy took a chance. It was great though!!!
Lauren - 1994 "I'm The Only One" - Melissa Ethridge
This song is great but with the flu, lets see how she does....Amazing voice and does the song justice. I've done this song sick and it's perfect so it's raspy. J. Lo she gave it country flavor and she made it her own. Randy: He liked it and hopes she has a cold every week. Steven: You are a shining star and agrees with Randy. I love the way she sang this. Hope that she chooses the next few songs wisely!
Jacob - 1987 "Alone" by Heart
OMG I didn't like this at all. The vibrato was too much and his breathing was crazy. He was just a little pitchy again! Randy: Very Nice out of comfort zone, lost yourself, didn't over power it. Steven: Gospel had a baby they would name it Jacob Lusk. J. Lo: You give yourself to every song, every moment and every note. You are so good. I disagree with the judges. I don't like him very much and his singing is best for old school songs but not rock. Stay away from Rock please!
These are my opinions and mine alone. Please let me know what you thought of these singers. Don't forget to download your favorites on iTunes now and all proceeds go to Japan Relief Fund!!
Black Eyed Peas Can't Get Enough and Lee Dewyze performing on the results show tomorrow on 3/17/11. Sorry I will not be able to watch due to St. Patrick's day and the San Jose Sharks Game!
No comments:
Post a Comment